The Happy Talent
  • Blog
  • About
  • Popular
  • Education
  • Social Science
  • Travel
  • Products
  • Contact
"It is a happy talent to know how to play."

If You Care About Women’s Rights, Stop Saying that Islam is a Religion of Peace.

6/21/2017

16 Comments

 
Picture
As feminists, we have to be able to speak honestly about patriarchal systems, and religion is no exception.
​

I wrote in a recent post that one of the best things in life is basketball. But another one of my favorite things... is critical thought. Debate. Confronting ideas that may be uncomfortable.

​Wherever you fall on the political spectrum, I hope we can all agree that no idea, ideology, or religion should be exempt from skepticism. 
​
Which is why I'm so stoked to share this amazing guest post by Shruthi Sailesh, who studies biotechnology and economics at the University of Waterloo. She enjoys debating and writing about politics, feminism, and literature. For more of her writing, follow her on Quora.
***

I know. You probably think I’m hateful and bigoted, and are proceeding to the comments section right now to say so. Before you do, hear me out. Whatever right-wing xenophobic nut you’re picturing in your head, I’m not it. I’m about as socially liberal as they come. Though I disagree with much of third-wave “feminism”, I am passionate about gender equality. That’s why I’m writing this. As feminists, we have to be able to speak honestly about patriarchal systems, and religion is no exception. Organized religion has long been intertwined with the oppression of women, but Islam in particular poses an unparalleled threat to women’s rights at this point in history. Islam is different; and it is intellectually dishonest to pretend otherwise.

Let’s get one thing straight right away; I am not attacking Muslims. I do not believe that all Muslims are violent terrorists; I am well aware of the fact that the vast majority of Muslims are peaceful, law-abiding citizens. That however, doesn’t change the fact that Islam as an ideology is fundamentally authoritarian, violent, and misogynistic. It isn’t “Islamophobic” to acknowledge that. As the writer Sam Harris so eloquently put it, “We are sold this meme of Islamophobia where every criticism of the doctrine of Islam gets conflated with bigotry against Muslims as people.”1
Picture
Picture
Picture

​You would think that modern feminists would devote more of their time and energy to the plight of Muslim women.
Muslim-majority countries consistently rank among the worst countries in the world for gender equality, and it doesn’t take a scholar to realize that the second-class status of women in the Muslim world is inextricably linked to Islamic scripture and doctrine. So why aren’t more Western feminists talking about it? Look at the scathing feminist critiques of fundamentalist Christianity; where is the equivalent for Islam? Where is the feminist outrage at honor killings, forced veiling, female genital mutilation, and Shariah law? Why are feminists, who can expound theses condemning lipstick and dolls, silent when it comes to the oppression of Muslim women?

Picture
​Let's ignore oppression in the Muslim world. It's much more important to talk about pumpkin spice lattes. 

Intersectional feminists are so obsessed with cultural sensitivity, so mired in collective white guilt, that they’ve succumbed to the “soft bigotry of low expectations” (to borrow a phrase from the writer Michael Gerson). How utterly hypocritical, to condemn misogyny when its perpetrators are white, but to turn a blind eye to horrific practices like FGM and honor killings, or worse still, defend them so as not to be branded as “racist” or “Islamophobic” (Germaine Greer, anyone?) Worse still,  Western feminists actively condemn those who speak out against Islam, accusing them of racism and bigotry and effectively shutting down honest debate.
 
Take Ayaan Hirsi Ali, for example. An ex-Muslim who was a victim of female genital mutilation as a child, she fled an arranged marriage and escaped to the Netherlands, eventually becoming a politician, writer, and fierce advocate for women’s rights. She is by all accounts a feminist hero. Yet, the leftist feminist critique of Hirsi Ali is so widespread that despite her liberal views, she took a position at the conservative think-tank the American Enterprise Institute. Imagine if Hirsi Ali had been a dissident and outspoken critic of Christianity instead. Is there any doubt that the left would have embraced her?
Picture
Picture
Picture

​Of course, intersectional feminists aren’t totally silent when it comes to Islam. They’ll talk about it,  but only when they want to make false equivalences and pat themselves on the back for acknowledging how terrible white people can be, too. Who hasn’t seen this image floating around, often accompanied by a sanctimonious caption meant to highlight how the poster is SO open-minded and tolerant? ​
Picture
(Image credit: Malcolm Evans)

It’s a misleading image on many levels, not least because no Western woman has ever been killed or threatened with rape because she refused to wear a bikini. Can the same be said of Muslim women and the veil?

The issue of the Islamic face veil is another article all together, but suffice to say that
the erasure of identity associated with the burqa or niqab would be seen as diametrically opposed to standard feminist theory...except when it comes to Islam, because that would be racist/bigoted/Islamophobic (take your pick). According to the left, all of the problems in the Muslim world can be traced back to Western colonialism and imperialism, and not, you know, the Islamic scriptures that are literally at the core of everything groups like ISIS and Al-Qaeda do.

 
The bottom line is that the regressive left’s empty rhetoric is hurting the very people they claim to stand for. By refusing to speak openly about Islam, intersectional feminists are silently condoning the atrocities that Muslim women all over the world face on a daily basis. A fundamentalist interpretation of Islam is incompatible with the fundamental values of Western democracy, and no amount of evasion, obfuscation and cognitive dissonance changes that. If you truly care about women’s rights, stop saying that Islam is a religion of peace.
 
In the words of Ayaan Hirsi Ali, “Some things must be said, and there are times when silence becomes an accomplice to injustice.”


Sources

https://www.city-journal.org/html/why-feminism-awol-islam-12395.html

http://nypost.com/2015/03/27/wrong-kind-of-hero-why-feminists-diss-hirsi-ali/

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/raza-habib-raja/women-in-muslim-countries_b_13741944.html

***

Author Bio: Shruthi studies biotechnology and economics at the University of Waterloo. She enjoys debating and writing about politics, feminism, and literature. For more of her writing, visit https://www.quora.com/profile/Shruthi-Sailesh.

16 Comments
Zane Kenney
6/21/2017 03:43:41 pm

I could not agree more. I'm a big fan of Sam Harris and Ayaan Hirsi Ali. Saying "Islam is a religion of peace" is like saying "Heroin is a safe medicine."

Reply
Liz
6/22/2017 01:58:16 am

I could not agree more as well. When Ayaan Hirsi Ali was disinvited from my alma mater (where she was slated to receive an honorary degree) for being "anti-Muslim," that's when I knew that third-wave feminism had jumped the shark. I guess the usual SJWs decided that "lived experience" didn't count this time (to say nothing of intellect, academic experience, etc).

Reply
Zane Kenney
6/22/2017 06:08:30 am

https://mobile.nytimes.com/2017/06/22/opinion/kamala-harris-islamism-senate-hearing.html?smprod=nytcore-iphone&smid=nytcore-iphone-share&_r=0&referer=https://www.theahafoundation.org/ayaan-hirsi-ali-and-asra-q-nomani-kamala-harris-was-silenced-then-she-silenced-us-the-new-york-times/

Reply
Jadzia
6/23/2017 01:03:18 pm

I once met two Pakistani women who were students at a top London University. They told me that when they tell white British people what things are like in their own country they are told that they must be wrong "because Islam is a religion of peace".

Reply
Eva Glasrud link
6/23/2017 01:16:36 pm

WOW. Talk about "whitesplaining."

Reply
Zeph
6/26/2017 12:52:15 pm

I definitely agree.

(Reminds me of the State Dept conflating any criticism of Israel's policies with per se anti-Semitism)

So - it's (sorta) easy to complain but what is the path to some solution? Saying "I'm not anti-Muslim, but I abhor the Islamic treatment of women" seems to be a hard needle to thread. And it begs the question of what we ARE for, specifically.

Do we advocate for the abolishment of Islam? For a religous "reform" (jumping into the whole schism issue; that always goes well)? Maybe for the wholesale secularization of the Islamic world (with greatly reduced social/political power for Islamic religion)? Or what?

It's easier to name the problem than to propose a workable solution. (That doesn't mean that covering it up is a "solution", tho; your point is taken).

Complicating it is that so many Muslim women (even a majority of those who have experienced FGM in many areas) support the Islamic practices. From our viewpoint they have been brainwashed into supporting their own oppression - but having some Western feminists telling them what they are supposed to feel is an obvious problem.

Perhaps all we can do is to try to open more space (somehow) for those Islamic women who do NOT accept the traditional practices.

Oddly, it's possible that watching western television and movies (sometimes identified as cultural imperialism) may do more to shift attitudes than any academic feminist critique. Yes, there are attempts to guide the interpretation (as well a filtering available sources), but feminist critiques are even less available (or interesting) to most citizens of the Islamic world.

Reply
Leslie
2/8/2018 12:43:04 pm

Part of the problem of fixing is that people refuse to see the problem in the first place, and if you point it out, you're a hateful bigot.

Reply
Amin Riadh
7/6/2017 07:09:53 pm

"That however, doesn’t change the fact that Islam as an ideology is fundamentally authoritarian, violent, and misogynistic."

Not quite...

Islam as an ideology is fundamentally as authoritarian, violent, and misogynistic as Christianity. And that is a fact. Because on those basis both religions more or less agree.

So how come you are Christian, Eva?

[Yes I am aware this is a guest post - however you are the one who has posted it on your blog - so you agree with the gist of it]






Reply
Leslie
2/8/2018 12:49:09 pm

You missed the point. The point wasn't putting Christianity on a platform, it was pointing out how Islam has become untouchable, even with obvious problems.

1400 little girls were raped in Britain, and the police didn't stop it because the perpetrators were Muslim.

Islam is still an ideology, and it should be OK to point out it's flaws as much as other people point out the flaws of say, Christianity without being shamed.

Reply
Anonymous
10/3/2019 12:19:34 pm

you said," 1400 little girls were raped in Britain, and the police didn't stop it because the perpetrators were Muslim."

lets say (for argument's sake) that these people were of some other religion (or atheists) and they said they were muslims just to defame the muslim name. How would you know the truth?

Let me tell you how. One can tell whether a person is a bona fide basketballer or not by observing how much he or she knows about basketball rules and how much of it he/she follows it (sorry for the bad example). We won't believe someone is a basketballer unless and until that person atleast a single goddamn thing about basketball. Similarly, one can tell whether a person is a muslim by observing how much he/she follows its rules and regulation and I'm PRETTY SURE there is not a single sentence that promotes rape (and I mean not even a SINGLE sentence).

So your logic of using this example of 1400 girls being raped is highly flawed.

Brien Doyle
1/13/2021 04:16:30 pm

'as authoritarian, violent, and misogynistic as Christianity'
True - in 3rd world countries and banana republics;
However xtianitly has been forced to tow the line under rules of laws in 1st world nations. It has been domesticated (altho still controlling in practice in many regions)

It is time to force religions into courts to force them to prove their claims
- as we do with Pharma and did with tobacco!!

Reply
Ayala
7/17/2017 09:30:05 pm

What a great insightful article! You are very talented as a writer

Reply
Brien Doyle
7/23/2017 01:18:35 am

I am blocked by Facebook from an 'offended' person after he said that Islam is a religion of peace and I said that he was a liar and printed a list of Islamic wars.
We need to sue FB.

Reply
Priya T
11/14/2017 12:15:58 pm

Great post! This is an issue on which I disagree with most third-wave "feminists" too. I have lived in close proximity to "moderate Islam" all my life and all around me and it has made ma radically feminist! Can't even imagine how the women in extremely Islamic countries like Saudi Arabia not become extremists! The power of indoctrination, no doubt. As an aside, I was not surprised to find the typical whatabouttery going on - what about Christianity... blah blah blah. Do these people go on breast cancer posts and say "what about prostate cancer? do you even know how dangerously sneaky that is! stop talking about breast cancer and taking focus away from prostate cancer, you prostater-phobes!" Sure, all religion is misogynistic, but few religions are practicing their misogyny in the current times with as much relish and approbation as Islam (although Hinduism with its honour killings and caste system comes pretty close, indistinguishable from Islam in select parts of India, really).

Reply
Yuki
1/12/2021 08:14:59 pm

So not only are you a narcissistic, disrespectful, entitled shit, you're also an anti-religion bigot. Okay then.

Reply
Brien Doyle
1/13/2021 04:10:47 pm

since the religions teach and practice bigotry - with other religions - with women - with Human rights.... it is appropriate to be bigoted against religions;
and Islam - with its repressive and totalitarian rules - in the civilised world - deserves the greatest amount of bigotry (that Islam itself has engendered!)

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    About the Author
    Picture
    Eva is a content specialist with a passion for play, travel... and a little bit of girl power.  Read more >


    Want to support The Happy Talent? CLICK HERE!
    Support the Happy Talent
    Or Find me on Patreon!
    Picture

    What's Popular on The Happy Talent:
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture

      Want more?

    Submit

    Trending in Dating and Relationships:
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture



    ​What's Popular in Science:
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture


    Playfulness and Leisure Skills:
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture

    Popular in Psychology and Social Skills:
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture

    Categories

    All
    20s
    Adolescence
    Backpacking
    Boredom
    Boredom Avoidance
    Camping
    Career Advice
    Careers
    Communication
    Confidence
    Consent
    Creativity
    Curiosity
    Dating
    Economy
    Education
    Entrepreneurship
    Fearlessness
    Female Travel
    Feminism
    Free Speech
    Gap Year
    Great Products
    Growth Mindset
    Health
    Hiking
    Hitchhiking
    Life Advice
    Meeting New People
    Mental Health
    Mexico
    Mindfulness
    Most Popular
    National Parks
    Outdoors
    Parenting
    Parenting Advice
    Passive Entertainment
    Play
    Playfulness
    Psychology
    Relationships
    Resilience
    Science
    Scuba Diving
    Self Help
    Self-help
    Sex
    Sports
    Stanford University
    Startups
    Study Abroad
    Summer
    Technology
    Teenagers
    Therapy
    Travel
    Yosemite

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly
Photos used under Creative Commons from paweesit, Steven Penton, torbakhopper, Theo Crazzolara, edenpictures, Kiwi Tom, Wrangell-St. Elias National Park, Homedust, wocintechchat.com, Ralphman, wbaiv, kg.abhi, Jamiecat *, UnitedWarVeterans, D()MENICK, True Portraits, Neville Wootton Photography, Salvation Army USA West, South African Tourism, phalinn, WilliamsProjects, j_bary, Japanexperterna.se, thephotographymuse, Elvert Barnes, ThoroughlyReviewed, hairy:jacques, joncutrer, wuestenigel, Franck_Michel, jimwerner25, Imahinasyon Photography, joanne clifford, m01229, Antonio Campoy Ederra, Our Dream Photography (Personal), shixart1985, davidstewartgets, couples in nature, Dage - Looking For Europe, jonseidman, andymw91, garryknight, wuestenigel, Rosmarie Voegtli, werner.philipps, Gage Skidmore, Novafly, dinuxm1, Eddie Yip, Prayitno / Thank you for (10 millions +) views, DMahendra, James_Seattle, jamkablam, vanitystudiosphotography, Luiz Gustavo Leme, oki_jappo, Daquella manera, CasparGirl, Mary Anne Morgan, inkknife_2000 (10.5 million + views), homethods, wocintechchat, Hypnotica Studios Infinite, dailyrectangle, Tobyotter, torbakhopper, Kevin Johnston, David Robb, eisenberg_emily, True Portraits, Douglas Pimentel, pmarkham, Noize Photography, rawdonfox, dollen, davidstewartgets, ed and eddie, Ryosuke Yagi, Anthony_Greene, Ruth and Dave, best couples, Jenn Durfey, Cost3l, Orin Zebest, anjanettew, dollen, Editor B, Alexander Day, LyndaSanchez, polosopuestosblog, UpSticksNGo, Agência Brasil, homethods, Find Rehab Centers, Novafly, Deornelas4, buzzern, seefit, C. VanHook (vanhookc), University of Delaware Alumni Relations, Franck_Michel, gordontarpley, Chris Photography(王權), usadifranci, virgohobbs, TheUglySweaterShop, popofatticus, Mitya Ku, Stefano Montagner - The life around me, Official U.S. Navy Imagery, xxxology, Valentina (GaiaPhotography), True Portraits, Lars Plougmann, Scioto Photos, Carlos ZGZ, quinn.anya, anokarina, amtecstaffing, mliu92, sfbaywalk, MakaiylaW, jerseytom55, Ray in Manila, BoldContent, stevenbates, Janitors, True Portraits, dwhartwig, Kuruman, sffoghorn
  • Blog
  • About
  • Popular
  • Education
  • Social Science
  • Travel
  • Products
  • Contact