The Happy Talent
  • Blog
  • About
  • Popular
  • Education
  • Social Science
  • Travel
  • Products
  • Contact
"It is a happy talent to know how to play."

Serious Question: What Rigors, Methodologies and Scholarly Qualities Characterize "Feminist Studies"? 

6/15/2016

2 Comments

 
Picture
So I heard a super interesting story about one of my favorite feminist scholars today.
Last year, campus Republicans announced that they would be hosting Christina Hoff Sommers at Oberlin College, and regressive liberals began organizing protests and safe spaces. (Did you know that students at Brown and Oberlin are so busy with their protests that they are failing out of their classes?) 

The outrage was so over-the-top that political commentator Bill Kristol invited Sommers to share her experience on his show. During the interview, Kristol asked, "How did this happen?" 

And so the story began...

***

​After earning her Ph.D. in philosophy from Brandeis University in 1979, Sommers earned a professor position at Clark University. After a few years, the chair of her department asked her to consider teaching feminist philosophy. Sommers thought, Well, okay, I'm a feminist, and I'm a philosopher, so why not?

But then something weird happened. 

She sent away for the textbooks, assuming that they would read like other philosophy texts: a collection of the best arguments about issues that concerned women -- affirmative action, abortion, maternity leave, etc.

The textbooks shocked her. According to Sommers, they presented what looked like a "conspiracy theory" against the patriarchy. The arguments weren't debates -- they were mutually reinforcing. She couldn't, in good conscience, use them.

"I just thought it was a sacred commandment of college teaching," Sommers told Kristol. "I never saw the classroom as a place to pass on my beliefs to students."
Save on textbooks with CampusBookRentals!

So she sent away for more textbooks-- and saw more of the same. So she went to the American Philosophy Association to raise her issues. She entered this presentation knowing that issues brought before the APA are always contentious -- but usually everyone, being reasonable adults, goes out for drinks after. 

Sommers recalls, "We did not go out for drinks after. There was hissing, and booing, and stamping their feet. And that evening, I was excommunicated from a religion I didn't even know existed."

Prior to this event, Sommers' articles had occasionally been included in feminist studies texts -- and after, that stopped. 

Someone was interested in hearing her thoughts on this, though: The Atlantic. They commissioned a piece from her, and she began doing research -- and was shocked by some of her findings. She read preposterous claims that were not backed by psychology and began further questioning feminist theories. 

Her article was never published in the Atlantic -- because the feminist philosophers found out she was writing it, and campaigned against the Atlantic. A version of it did appear in the New Republic -- and, ultimately, the research culminated in her 1995 book, Who Stole Feminism? How Women Have Betrayed Women. 
Picture
(In 2015, she also published The War Against Boys: How Misguided Policies are Harming Our Young Men, which is also worth reading, even though I don't agree with all of it.)

***

I find it fascinating how Sommers stumbled upon what ended up being an incredible career for her -- and, while I don't agree with everything she writes, I continue to be fascinated by her process and her arguments.

But here's what I want to know:

In spite of getting my first A+ at Stanford in Gender Psychology, I don't actually know a whole lot about "Feminist Studies" or "Feminist Theory." I guess I'd always assumed that it was like an extended version of my Gender Psychology class, where you learn about biological and psychological differences between men and women.

I always assumed it has its own rigors and methodologies. I assumed it used the scientific method of thinking. I assumed healthy amounts of skepticism were encouraged. 

But, as of the late 1980s, this was not Sommers' experience. 

Has this changed? Has the field matured and developed? In what ways is it scholarly and objective? What are the standards, rigors and methodologies that characterize feminist studies? In the typical Feminist Studies class, do actual debates happen? Do textbooks present actual conflicting views -- or are arguments still mutually reinforcing?

​This is a serious question. ​I would love to hear the experience and perspectives of current feminist studies majors. 
2 Comments
T L
9/9/2021 11:12:59 pm

hi, could you please elaborate as to what, among sommer's arguments, you disagree with?

Reply
Eva Glasrud link
9/14/2021 05:23:31 pm

In general, I agree with a lot of her earlier feminism stuff, and I agree with her criticisms of extreme, regressive feminism. I agree that women are warriors, not butterflies, and that we shouldn't treat them like they're so fragile. I also enjoyed her book, One Nation Under Therapy: How the Helping Culture is Eroding Self-Reliance (https://amzn.to/3kbjWQJ). I agreed with a lot of what she wrote, but I'm ambivalent about the chapter about addiction, just because I don't know enough to have a strong opinion.

Currently, I think her Twitter fame has gone to her head a bit, and she's getting a little sensational and trumpy, and less skeptical and outspoken.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    About the Author
    Picture
    Eva is a content specialist with a passion for play, travel... and a little bit of girl power.  Read more >


    Want to support The Happy Talent? CLICK HERE!
    Support the Happy Talent
    Or Find me on Patreon!
    Picture

    What's Popular on The Happy Talent:
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture

      Want more?

    Submit

    Trending in Dating and Relationships:
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture



    ​What's Popular in Science:
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture


    Playfulness and Leisure Skills:
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture

    Popular in Psychology and Social Skills:
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture

    Categories

    All
    20s
    Adolescence
    Backpacking
    Boredom
    Boredom Avoidance
    Camping
    Career Advice
    Careers
    Communication
    Confidence
    Consent
    Creativity
    Curiosity
    Dating
    Economy
    Education
    Entrepreneurship
    Fearlessness
    Female Travel
    Feminism
    Free Speech
    Gap Year
    Great Products
    Growth Mindset
    Health
    Hiking
    Hitchhiking
    Life Advice
    Meeting New People
    Mental Health
    Mexico
    Mindfulness
    Most Popular
    National Parks
    Outdoors
    Parenting
    Parenting Advice
    Passive Entertainment
    Play
    Playfulness
    Psychology
    Relationships
    Resilience
    Science
    Scuba Diving
    Self Help
    Self-help
    Sex
    Sports
    Stanford University
    Startups
    Study Abroad
    Summer
    Technology
    Teenagers
    Therapy
    Travel
    Yosemite

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly
Photos used under Creative Commons from paweesit, Steven Penton, torbakhopper, Theo Crazzolara, edenpictures, Kiwi Tom, Wrangell-St. Elias National Park, Homedust, wocintechchat.com, Ralphman, wbaiv, kg.abhi, Jamiecat *, UnitedWarVeterans, D()MENICK, True Portraits, Neville Wootton Photography, Salvation Army USA West, South African Tourism, phalinn, WilliamsProjects, j_bary, Japanexperterna.se, thephotographymuse, Elvert Barnes, ThoroughlyReviewed, hairy:jacques, joncutrer, wuestenigel, Franck_Michel, jimwerner25, Imahinasyon Photography, joanne clifford, m01229, Antonio Campoy Ederra, Our Dream Photography (Personal), shixart1985, davidstewartgets, couples in nature, Dage - Looking For Europe, jonseidman, andymw91, garryknight, wuestenigel, Rosmarie Voegtli, werner.philipps, Gage Skidmore, Novafly, dinuxm1, Eddie Yip, Prayitno / Thank you for (10 millions +) views, DMahendra, James_Seattle, jamkablam, vanitystudiosphotography, Luiz Gustavo Leme, oki_jappo, Daquella manera, CasparGirl, Mary Anne Morgan, inkknife_2000 (10.5 million + views), homethods, wocintechchat, Hypnotica Studios Infinite, dailyrectangle, Tobyotter, torbakhopper, Kevin Johnston, David Robb, eisenberg_emily, True Portraits, Douglas Pimentel, pmarkham, Noize Photography, rawdonfox, dollen, davidstewartgets, ed and eddie, Ryosuke Yagi, Anthony_Greene, Ruth and Dave, best couples, Jenn Durfey, Cost3l, Orin Zebest, anjanettew, dollen, Editor B, Alexander Day, LyndaSanchez, polosopuestosblog, UpSticksNGo, Agência Brasil, homethods, Find Rehab Centers, Novafly, Deornelas4, buzzern, seefit, C. VanHook (vanhookc), University of Delaware Alumni Relations, Franck_Michel, gordontarpley, Chris Photography(王權), usadifranci, virgohobbs, TheUglySweaterShop, popofatticus, Mitya Ku, Stefano Montagner - The life around me, Official U.S. Navy Imagery, xxxology, Valentina (GaiaPhotography), True Portraits, Lars Plougmann, Scioto Photos, Carlos ZGZ, quinn.anya, anokarina, amtecstaffing, mliu92, sfbaywalk, MakaiylaW, jerseytom55, Ray in Manila, BoldContent, stevenbates, Janitors, True Portraits, dwhartwig, Kuruman, sffoghorn
  • Blog
  • About
  • Popular
  • Education
  • Social Science
  • Travel
  • Products
  • Contact